Conduct

When no one is watching

I’ve always had a great deal of respect for the medical profession.

Unlike lawyers, accountants, Realtors, or even the clergy, the decisions they make affect life and limb. For doctors, ethical conduct isn’t just a means of maintaining the public trust; it’s an essential to their mandate of saving lives.

My doctor has this sign posted on her door:

 

 

To me, it demonstrates the importance of a values-based ethics system, over a rule-based ethics system.

In the end, we might be accountable to our clients and the profession. But if your values lead you to act ethically only when you are being watched, are you really an ethical professional?

Teaching Ethics in a Recession

Paul Horowitz at PrawfsBlawg has noticed that the economy appears to have an influence on how law students approach problems in legal ethics.

In particular, students seem to adhere to a more client-loyal view of legal ethics, rather than espousing the overarching duties that lawyers have to the court. This, Professor Horowitz says, leads students in class discussions to give answers that are aimed at keeping the client, rather than providing recommendations that might risk having the client take the file elsewhere. In addition, students tend to favour non-disclosure where ethical rules are permissive about the breach of confidentiality.

The post, and the observations in it, are fascinating. But they reveal the weaknesses inherent in a rule-based approach to ethics, as opposed to a values-based approach.

More

Pot Bust Goes Awry – Law Prof Threatens to Sue

Police in the San Francisco suburb of Castro apparently botched a drug raid on a private home on January 11, 2011, breaking in and placing law professor Clark Freshman in handcuffs, over his objections that police had the wrong house.

In fact, the information in support of the warrant indicated that police had cased the home for 2 days, but still provided an inaccurate description of the building they raided.

If that is true, it’s reprehensible.

My concern, however, is with the good professor’s own conduct.

More

Update: Legal Ethics Hero Greg Adler, and the Bay Area Towing Scam Update

Last month, I wrote about Greg Adler’s exemplary conduct in exposing Vincent Cardinalli and Paul Greer’s towing scam in the San Francisco Bay area.

Now, NBC thinks enough of Greg Adler’s heroism to run its own story about the case.

More

Run for the Border: Practicing Across Jurisdictions

In Canada, lawyers enjoy a great deal of freedom to practice outside their home provinces. Generally, if a lawyer has no pending criminal or disciplinary proceedings, and has no disciplinary record, he can practice in any Canadian province other than Quebec for up to 100 days per year without advising the host province’s law society.

This has given lawyers, particularly those in smaller jurisdictions such as Prince Edward Island, a lot of freedom to expand their practices to neighboring provinces.

The agreement that allows for this kind of temporary (and permanent) practice mobility between the common law provinces seems to be working extremely well. It offers members of our profession great opportunities to learn and experience different approaches to common procedural problems – as well as, occasionally, to common problems in the substantive law. That sort of breadth and depth of knowledge translates to a more flexible profession that is able to offer clients more options when it comes to trying to solve difficult legal issues.

But it also raises some interesting ethical issues, both for the lawyers who find themselves in another jurisdiction, as well as for the judges before whom those lawyers appear.

More