Judicial independence

On the Making of Judges: the Bastarache Inquiry

The Bastarache Inquiry has prompted a lot of people in this country to seriously question our system of appointing judges.

But if there is a crisis of confidence, is it because the system is flawed? Or is it because of the way politicians operate it?

More

New allegations against Manitoba judge

A Winnipeg woman has complained to the Canadian Judicial Council regarding the conduct of Justice Lori Douglas.

The complainant alleges that pictures of Justice Douglas having an aspect of bondage and sado-masochism raise a reasonable apprehension of bias in proceedings in which she was involved.

The woman applied for a prevention order against her estranged husband.  Justice Douglas heard the motion, and refused to grant the order.  Instead, Justice Douglas issued a no-contact order that applied to both parties.

More

The secret lives of judges – Part II

This is the second of a two part series on why, in my view, Justice Lori Douglas of the Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench is, through no fault of her own, not in a position to continue in her position.

The background is set out in Part I.

More

The secret lives of judges – Part I

For a professional person, the notion that one’s professional life can be insulated from one’s personal life is pure fiction.

That will undoubtedly be the lesson Justice Lori Douglas, and her husband, lawyer Jack King take from the embarrassing circumstances in which they now find themselves.

More

Oil spills, personal finance, and judicial ethics

By now, most people know that after the sinking of British Petroleum’s Deepwater Horizon rig, and the resulting oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, the Obama administration imposed a six-month moratorium on offshore drilling.

A number of companies that ferry people and supplies and provide other services to offshore rigs challenged the moratorium in the U.S. Federal Court.

On June 21, 2010, Judge Martin Feldman issued a ruling that overturned the moratorium.

It’s since emerged that Judge Feldman has a number of investments in the oil industry, which has lead WSJ Law Blog to ask if he should have stepped aside.

Probably not.

More